ACT leader calls Catholic bishops liars

ACT leader David Seymour reminds Catholic Bishops of The Commandments

Monday, September 21st, 2020

ACT leader David Seymour, Wednesday, issued a reminder to the New Zealand Catholic Bishops to keep the Commandments.

In a statement on the End of Life Choice Act, Seymour singled out New Zealand’s Catholic Bishops and told them they needed to follow the ninth commandment and to ‘stop bearing false witness against their neighbours in political debates”.

Suggesting a view in a public debate which is different to his is a false witness, (a lie), Seymour’s statement threatens, “If the Bishops want their freedoms respected, they need to engage in honest debate that respects others have difference [sic] choices from theirs.”

Seymour’s comments come after 37 of New Zealand’s most prominent religious leaders, including the New Zealand Catholic Bishops say New Zealanders need to be aware of the considerable harm that the End of Life Choice Act could do.

The statement is authorised by Archbishop Philip Richardson, Primate, Senior Bishop of the New Zealand Pakeha Diocese and Bishop of Diocese of Waikato and Taranaki.

The leaders say that in their caring roles they come face to face with people who are dying and their families, and they understand how vulnerable people are at the end of their life.

“Our concerns are about the unintended consequences for the most vulnerable”, the religious leaders say in the statement.

They say their communities include lawyers who think the End of Life Choice Act is badly-drafted law and that it lacks critical safeguards present in similar overseas laws.

They also say they have listened to the concerns of doctors who work on the front line of end-of-life care.

“Our opposition to this Act reflects our compassion for those who will experience a wrongful premature death because of the dangers of this Act; in particular those who will feel coerced into an early death, whether because of their own feelings of being a burden or because of overt pressure from others”, the leaders say.

The religious leaders point out that the referendum is a binding referendum, meaning the Act will be enacted in its current form and cannot be changed.

The leader’s statement reads

At the upcoming general election, you will be asked to vote in a binding referendum on the End of Life Choice Act, 2019.

We the undersigned religious leaders, wish to share with you our grave concerns about the final form of this Act.

We speak out of our extensive experience of caring for the dying.

We know the effectiveness of compassionate end of life palliative care – care that is able to address not just the physical suffering of people who are dying, but also their emotional, spiritual and psychological suffering, as well as that of whānau and friends.

Medical practices that are part of good end-of-life care – ceasing treatment, Do Not Resuscitate Orders, Advanced Care Directives and turning off life support – are already legal and part of our health care choices and are not part of this proposed law.

The referendum question is not about the desirability of some form of ‘assisted dying’. Rather, we are being asked to vote on a specific piece of legislation – the End of Life Choice Act. The key consideration for all of us is the robustness and safety of this Act. Our concerns are about the lack of safeguards in the Act and the dangers it would present.

We note that the Act differs in the quality of its processes and safeguards from other laws overseas:

The Act is not just designed for a small number of hard cases. It is broader than laws in Victoria and the United States because it allows both assisted suicide and euthanasia.
This is not an Act of ‘last resort’ – there is no requirement to try effective treatments or palliative care. There is also no corresponding right in the proposed law for people to access palliative care.
People will be able to access an assisted death without being in any physical pain. Overseas statistics show people choose assisted death primarily out of a fear of being a burden and/or being disabled.
The Act does not require a patient to discuss their decision with a family member or other significant person. All eligible persons, 18 years and over, could choose an assisted death without family knowing.
There is no mandatory psychological assessment or effective screening for depression. Research shows that requests for an assisted death are commonly influenced by depression, something that is extremely difficult to detect and often mistaken for ‘appropriate sadness’.
The NZ Medical Association and Hospice NZ, who oppose the Act,3 share concerns that it lacks processes enabling clinicians to be confident a person is making their request free of pressure from others.
The two doctor ‘safeguard’ is weak; neither of the doctors needs to have met the person previously.
There is no mandatory stand-down period as there is in other countries – under the Act, a person could be dead less than 4 days after diagnosis.
Unlike laws overseas, there is no requirement for independent observers or witnesses at any stage.
The Act does not require a person to be assessed for competency at the time when the lethal dose is being administered, as is the case with laws overseas.

The referendum is binding, meaning the Act cannot be changed – it will be enacted in its current form.

We are also concerned that the practice of assisted suicide and euthanasia will become normalised over time, leading to a broadening of the criteria for eligibility as seen overseas.

There is also evidence showing that people choose assisted death because of a lack of adequate care options. There is a risk this will also happen in New Zealand, especially because effective palliative care is not yet universally available to all.

We acknowledge the importance of exercising freedom of choice.

At the same time, there is a need to balance individual choice with the common good of society. On balance, we believe that the significant weaknesses and dangers of the Act strongly outweigh the benefits that supporters of euthanasia seek.

Archbishop Philip Richardson – Primate, Senior Bishop of the New Zealand Pakeha Diocese and Bishop of Diocese of Waikato and Taranaki
Bishop Jay Behan – Church of Confessing Anglicans, Aotearoa New Zealand
Pastor Steve Burgess – Regional Director, C3 Church Pacific
Commissioner Mark Campbell – Territorial Commander, Salvation Army, New Zealand Territory
Bishop Patrick Dunn – President of the NZ Catholic Bishops Conference; Catholic Diocese of Auckland
Dr Mustafa Farouk QSM – President, The Federation of Islamic Associations of NZ (FIANZ)
Rev Tavita Joseph Filemoni – General Secretary, Wesleyan Samoan Methodist Church of New Zealand and Australia
Charles Hewlett – National Leader of the Baptist Churches of New Zealand
Rev Brett Jones – National Superintendent (Acting), Wesleyan Methodist Church of New Zealand
Right Reverend Fakaofo Kaio – Moderator, The Presbyterian Church in New Zealand
Metropolitan Myron – New Zealand Greek Orthodox Church
Rev Dr Stuart Lange – National Director, New Zealand Christian Network
Pastor David MacGregor – National Director, Vineyard Church Christchurch
Rev Andrew Marshall – National Director, Alliance Churches of New Zealand
Pastor Peter Morlock – Senior Pastor, City Impact Churches of New Zealand
Archbishop Don Tamihere – Primate, Pihopa o Aotearoa and Pihopa o Te Tairawhiti
Rev Setaita Taumoepeau K. Viekune – President, Methodist Church of New Zealand
Pastor Adam White – Leader, New Life Churches of New Zealand
Bishop Mark Whitfield – Lutheran Church of New Zealand
Bishop Ross Bay – Anglican Diocese of Auckland
Bishop Steven Benford – Anglican Diocese of Dunedin
Bishop Peter Carrel – Anglican Diocese of Christchurch
Cardinal John Dew – Catholic Archdiocese of Wellington
Bishop Michael Dooley – Catholic Diocese of Dunedin
Bishop Justin Duckworth – Anglican Diocese of Wellington
Pastor Max Faletutulu – Senior Pastor, Titahi Bay Community Church, Wellington
Bishop Michel Gielen – Catholic Diocese of Auckland – Auxiliary
Bishop Andrew Henge – Anglican Diocese of Waiapu
Bishop Stephen Lowe – Catholic Diocese of Hamilton
Bishop Steve Maina – Anglican Diocese of Nelson
Pastor Kaio Mamea – Light of All Nations Church, Wellington
Bishop Paul Martin SM – Catholic Diocese of Christchurch
Bishop Te Kitohi Pikaahu – Pihopatanga o Te Taitokerau
Bishop Waitohiariki Quayle – Pihopatanga o Te Upoko o Te Ika
Rt Revd Dr Eleanor Sanderson – Assistant Anglican Bishop of Wellington
Bishop Richard Wallace – Pihopatanga o Te Waipounamu
Rev Brian Walsh – Local Administrator, Catholic Diocese of Palmerston North.