Prelate suggests excommunication for strident Pope critics

Friday, December 11th, 2015

A prelate has suggested that strident criticism of Pope Francis might be grounds for excommunication under canon law.

Archbishop Rino Fisichella, president of the Pontifical Council for the New Evangelisation, suggested such criticism could be seen as akin to “physical violence” against the Roman Pontiff.

This carries a penalty of excommunication.

But US canon lawyer Ed Peters said provisions in canon law must be interpreted narrowly and physical violence means what it says – physical violence.

While hateful speech is objectively sinful, it is not a canonical crime punishable by excommunication, the canonist said.

Additional reading

News category: News Shorts.

Tags: Archbishop Fisichella, Canon Law, Ed Peters, excommunication, Pope Francis, Speech

Fifth Gospel Living – book review

Simple, sweet, sometimes heart-breaking, and always invigorating, Fifth Gospel Living is the latest publication from Fr John O’Connor and his Food for Faith ministry. It comprises stories of personal encounters with God. The 96 reflections are the result of a Read more

Treaty of Waitangi should be considered as a covenant relationship

A hīkoi opposing the Treaty Principles Bill has made its way to Wellington. Those who took part in the hīkoi, along with supporters around the country, both Māori and non-Māori, consider the Bill to be a betrayal of the commitments Read more

Christianity stands on threshold of new Reformation

Keynote speaker Tomáš Halík (pictured) a leading Catholic intellectual and author from the Czech Republic, says Churches must transcend national, religious, cultural boundaries A new reformation for the 21st century must transcend “the current forms and boundaries of Christianity,” resist Read more

CathNews New Zealand